Plate Compactor VS Jumping Jack: How to Choose the Right Company?

Plate Compactor VS Jumping Jack : Searching for an answer on how to choose between a plate compactor and a jumping jack? There’s no need to look any further. A thorough guide on determining the right construction tool will be provided. 

The two most common types of compactors are plate compactors and jumping jacks. In spite of the fact that both work to create a sturdy, dynamic foundation, they have fundamental differences.

Choosing which one to hire for the short-term has a lot to do with what you want to accomplish. Alternatively, before making a purchase, you might consider hiring them to find out if they’re compatible.

In both cases, we would ask you to read the following narrative. You will absolutely love the detailed comparison of these two prominent compactors.

Plate Compactor VS. Jumping Jack Analysis

Despite being used for the same purpose, these two contractors differ in a few fundamental ways. Here’s a look at what makes them different. 

 

Soil Type

Your first consideration should be the type of soil on your construction site. Most soils fall into one of two categories:

  • Granular/Gravel soil
  • Cohesive soil

Two different types of compacting equipment are needed for these two types of soils. 

Granular soil does not have any cohesive strength since it does not contain clay. In this way, it can be compacted wet or dry. In addition, they contain visible and large particles. 

Plate compactors are the best tools for compacting these types of soil since they respond very well to vibrations. In addition, vibrating plate compactors spread vibration over a wider surface area. The granular materials are therefore settled down as best as they can. 

See also  The Difference Between Dual Action vs Random Orbital Polisher

Clay materials are more prevalent in cohesive lands. Therefore, they cannot be compacted when dry. In order for them to be compacted properly, a specific amount of moisture is needed. 

The jumping jack or the rammer are the best tools to work with cohesive soils due to their small plates. Due to their suitability for 13% moist soil, they will have better compaction on clay-based soils. 

The smaller plates combust more effectively if they are firm. You can also solidify soil deeper with them than with plate compactors. This is due to the direct force exerted by the plates. 

Wider or Narrower Spot

Rammers are narrower than plate compactors, as previously stated. Consequently, they are more suitable for contracting in larger areas. So, they are easier to use in flat areas. 

With vibrating compactors, for example, you can compact asphalt areas, parking lots, sub-base surfaces, etc. in the same way. 

In contrast, jack rammers are ideal for trenches and small, tight areas. With a tamping rammer, you can easily compact material that you cannot reach with a plate compactor. 

Plates with slim and sleek designs help you compact perfectly on a tight space. 

Easy Operation

When using a compactor, comfort is equally important to competence. Skillful maneuvering is easier with a vibrating compactor. Vibration can also be reduced by handles on many machines.

With smaller plates, jumping jacks work well, but they need more effort and power to be successful. In addition to providing professional services, they provide a wide range of support services.

What Kind of Professional to Hire

You should study your project before hiring a piece of compaction equipment. Considering the above factors, you will be able to easily determine the type of machine you need based on the needs of your workplace.

If you are working on a flat surface with a wider area, the plate compactor is the safer choice. However, if you need to work in tight spots or trenches, a rammer is the best tool. 

Obviously, a jumping jack won’t work if the soil is granular. Vibrating compactors are the only machines that can save you. You should also decide whether you want flawless performance or easy handling. One such suggestion, of course, is to hire a plate compactor. Choosing option two will result in a fast filling with deep contraction.

In my expert opinion, you should try a jumping jack or a plate compactor, depending on the location. You should first determine what you will be compacting before choosing a compactor.

Only using the right equipment for the right project will bring the expected outcome. Otherwise, your sweat-earned money will be wasted.

We have made a table below which shows the opposing factors of both in order to help you better understand.

See also  Benchtop vs Floor Drill Press : What Is The Best Option

Conclusion

Neither are effective enough to deliver a well-compacted base for a construction job, when using a plate compactor or jumping jack. However, their methods of compacting are different. 

A granular soil might use one, while a cohesive soil might use the other. Consider the type of soil you will compact before choosing a compactor. Both soil types do not suit one another.

Using both of these tools will reduce unsettlement in the soil and volume changes. Hopefully, this discussion helped you select your correct compactor from these two choices.

 

Leave a Comment